Menu
Review Highlights
“The sandwiches in a shape of a 30 was a great touch, chicken cutlet and Italian sandwiches with fresh bread was so good.” in 3 reviews
$16 Fried Chicken Cutlets“The staff is superlative : Tom, the owner, the managers; Bob the top manager & managers; Liz & Kaitlin & the staff; Ryan, Joe, Jenna, Brooke.” in 2 reviews
“. They'll heat these up for you if you ask at the deli counter” in 2 reviews
Location & Hours
You Might Also Consider
in Vietnamese, Noodles, Sandwiches
in Wraps, Pizza, Salad
Amenities and More
About the Business
Business owner information
Tom B.
Specializing in catering,Antipasto,Cheese and fruit Platters..Specialty Roasts ,Beef ,Pork Chicken And Turkey
Ask the Community
Yelp users haven’t asked any questions yet about Beyar's Market.
Recommended Reviews
Overall rating
41 reviews
5 stars
4 stars
3 stars
2 stars
1 star
- Gregory B.Pompano Beach, FL0131Dec 31, 2023
This place makes amazing Italian sandwich's. They have all the best you can imagine. Fried eggplant and Italian roasted peppers are delicious don't forget the fresh mozzarella. Enjoy
Helpful 0Thanks 0Love this 0Oh no 0 - Amanda H.Staten Island, NY5675Mar 3, 2023
Two words... MACARONI SALAD. the best I've ever had. Sometimes I find myself craving it, lol.
Even if you're not a macaroni salad person, try this one! It's not like commercial one, with the very chemically mayo and the weird aftertaste. This is fresh with onion and peppers and black pepper. Oh man, so good.
Tuna salad is good too!
The Italian bread is always perfect.
It's a cute little neighborhood marketHelpful 0Thanks 0Love this 0Oh no 0 - Karen K.Staten Island, NY01Sep 25, 2023
This is my go to place for chicken cutlet sandwiches and home made salads.
Also use for all catering needs. Truly delicious food.Helpful 0Thanks 0Love this 0Oh no 0 - Matt C.Staten Island, Staten Island, NY07Aug 17, 2023
Unfortunately as much as the staff is kind and clean great place every single time I've ordered sandwiches no matter a BLT , or BEC it is always wrong and/or undercooked and missing ingredients. And for sandwiches I can get anywhere else for cheaper price and made right but always went back to give them another chance because I want to give them the business. At this point over 20+ attempts I don't think I'll be ordering sandwiches from them again.
Helpful 3Thanks 0Love this 0Oh no 0 - Claire G.San Francisco, CA02Dec 17, 2023
I had a wonderful experience catering breakfast for a group of 55. Food was plentiful and very well prepared. Bob was a pleasure to work with.
Helpful 0Thanks 0Love this 0Oh no 0 - Aldo R.Staten Island, Staten Island, NY011Jul 7, 2023
Food always fresh and service always friendly. Parking lot makes shopping here very convenient as well.
Helpful 0Thanks 0Love this 0Oh no 0 - Lori S.Staten Island, NY025Oct 26, 2022Updated review
This is a superior store. It's always well stocked & fresh. Terrific service at check out & the deli, as well as anywhere else in the store that you may need assistance. Everyone is so welcoming & congenial. They really care about customer service & treat you as a person not just a number.
The staff is superlative :
Tom, the owner, the managers; Bob the top manager & managers; Liz & Kaitlin & the staff; Ryan, Joe, Jenna, Brooke. The Deli Dept is absolutely wonderful. They go out of their way for you & their chicken salad is unbeatable. Jack is outstanding.
Lastly, the prices are fabulous. Beyars carries things that other stores do not have such as fresh mint, carrots jubilee & exquisite custom cakes & pies plus the best dark chocolate.
Lastly they are always patient & kind on the phone esp w my Saturday inquiry calls.
Thank you !!Helpful 0Thanks 0Love this 0Oh no 0Oct 19, 2018Previous reviewthis is such a great store with everything you need plus great employees that give outstanding service: ro in deli, the owner & also the manager, bob & employees liz, ryan & gary! thank you, beyers!!!!
- Joe M.Toms River, NJ02Jan 25, 2023
Ordered the chicken florentine lunch special on sourdough bread the worst excuse for a panini I've ever had. Sandwich had a few slice of deli chicken and a ton of unmelted cheese. The bread wasn't toasted and the florentine was a few leaves of raw baby spinach. I work on the island and will make sure I don't go back to this place.
Helpful 3Thanks 0Love this 0Oh no 0 - Shawn Z.Staten Island, Staten Island, NY0339Aug 2, 2022
Beyars has a nice deli selection. A great local place to grab anything you need. A professional friendly staff is also a plus.
Helpful 0Thanks 0Love this 0Oh no 0 - Pat L.Staten Island, Staten Island, NY141Sep 15, 2020
The worst food ever‼chicken cutlets no taste, rice ball's no taste, fresh must, no taste‼
Everything I bought went right in the garbage ‼ I will never buy anything the have in their deli case. Whoever is preparing the food in the case needs to learn how to cook, the "fresh" nuts tasted like chalk I'll stick with La Bella, Top Tomato, Pastosa .Helpful 4Thanks 0Love this 0Oh no 0
You Might Also Consider
in Bagels, Chicken Wings, Breakfast & Brunch
in Pizza, Italian